What the Next Generation of Lawyers Needs From Its Leaders (And Why Your Firm's Success Depends on It)

I've spent most of my career in the legal profession, first as a lawyer and law firm partner and now as a leadership coach working with lawyers and the people who lead them. Over that time, there's one question I keep coming back to.

We spend years developing great lawyers. Are we putting the same effort into developing great leaders?

The shift from great lawyer to great leader nobody prepares you for.

Let's think about the road to partnership. It's years of study and years of practice, building technical expertise, client relationships, commercial nous and a reputation for being exceptionally good at what you do. And rightly so, because that's the foundation of a successful legal career. But somewhere along the way, the job changes.

You're no longer just responsible for your own work, your own clients and your own performance. Now you're responsible for other people: their development, their performance, their confidence and their careers. I found this shift very challenging as a reasonably young manager in my law firm.

Leadership asks you to do things that run against much of what made you successful as a lawyer. It asks you to:

  • let other people find the answers

  • hand over work you know you could do faster yourself

  • have the difficult conversation rather than quietly fixing the problem

  • measure your success by what the people around you achieve, not only by what you achieve yourself.

That's a huge shift, and it doesn't happen automatically when you make partner.

I think our profession often confuses professional progression with leadership development. We recognise someone's technical expertise and their ability to build a practice, and we assume leadership will follow. Sometimes it does, but often it doesn't.

The law firm leadership model we inherited.

Ask any Generation X lawyer (myself included) what leadership looked like during their articles of clerkship and watch what happens. There's a pause, and then a story, usually about a partner who was brilliant, formidable and largely unavailable. You didn't interrupt unless you absolutely had to, and if you did, you'd better have your facts straight, your authorities tabbed and your question rehearsed.

Those partners were leaders, and nobody questioned it. They knew the law better than anyone in the firm. Their authority came from what they knew, and it was rarely tested. We learned by watching, copying and fumbling our way through, and while it worked, nobody would design it that way now.

Why law firm leadership is now a business problem.

Our profession has changed, and the evidence on what the old model costs us is no longer anecdotal.

In 2025, researchers from the Australian National University and the University of Melbourne surveyed around 1,900 lawyers across Victoria, New South Wales and Western Australia. A third wanted to quit their firm, one in 10 planned to leave the profession altogether within a year, and around half said their workplace culture had a negative effect on their wellbeing. (Ouch!)

The 2025 Victorian Lawyer Census paints an equally confronting picture. More than half the lawyers surveyed were experiencing psychological distress, with 13% at severe levels, and among lawyers aged 20 to 29 that severe figure rose to 20%. More than half were at risk of burnout, and a quarter were at very high risk.

When the College of Law asked lawyers why they were unhappy, the reasons included a toxic workplace, poor management and leadership, and unsatisfactory pay. Its 2025 research also found that balance was the most important factor for legal professionals considering a role, ahead of a competitive salary and career advancement.

So it's no surprise that the 2026 ALPMA and Elias Recruitment survey named retention the number one HR priority for legal employers this year, with the highest churn in early career roles.

Leadership isn't a side issue in the retention conversation. It is the conversation.

When leadership isn't working, the firm pays for it:

  • Talent walks. Senior associates leave and take their knowledge, their client relationships and your investment in them out the door.

  • Margins shrink. Partner-rate work, write-offs and rehiring costs come straight off the bottom line.

  • The pipeline stalls. You're left with plenty of brilliant technicians but too few leaders ready to step up.

  • Growth hits a ceiling. A firm can only grow as fast as the people leading it.

These aren't simply leadership challenges. They're business challenges.

What the next generation of lawyers needs from its leaders.

So, what do the lawyers coming through actually want from their leaders?

They want learning that's deliberate rather than absorbed by osmosis, and they want coaching. They want feedback that's specific and regular, not an annual review that lands six months after the moment has passed. They want to understand why a decision was made, not simply be told what it is. And they want flexibility as an expectation rather than a concession.

Underneath all of that sit three things:

  1. Trust. Leadership runs on it. Without it, you only get compliance, not commitment.

  2. Sense making. In times of rapid change, people don't need a leader with every answer. They need someone who can help them make sense of what's happening, whether that's what a restructure means for the team or what good looks like in their role in the next six months.

  3. Believability. It's no longer enough to be right: you have to be believed. That means being visible, consistent and human enough that people trust your account of the world.

Why leadership is genuinely hard for lawyers.

Here's the uncomfortable part, and it's why generic leadership training so often falls flat in law firms.

Dr Larry Richard of LawyerBrain LLC has spent more than two decades studying lawyer personality, testing thousands of lawyers across the US and Canada. His research shows lawyers are outliers, and the very traits that make us excellent at the law are the ones that test us most as leaders.

Source: Dr Larry Richard, LawyerBrain LLC, Caliper Profile research on lawyer personality.
TraitWhere lawyers scoreWhat it means for leadership
ScepticismAround the 90th percentileBrilliant for protecting clients, but sits in direct tension with trust
AutonomyAround the 89th percentileMakes delegation harder than it should be
UrgencyHighMakes us responsive, but often poor listeners
SociabilityAround the 13th percentileTests our ability to connect
ResilienceLow: more than 90% fall in the bottom halfShapes how we give and receive feedback

Then there's the finding I often think about. When Richard began this work, lawyers scored slightly above average on empathy. Today, lawyer empathy sits in the low 40s, and it's been falling steadily for a decade. It's a trend he sees across society, not just in law, but empathy is declining in our profession at precisely the moment our people most need it from us.

Now, don't misunderstand me: none of this makes lawyers bad leaders. These traits are exactly what make us very good at the work. But they do mean the move from great lawyer to great leader takes conscious effort, not just good intentions.

Why law firm leadership matters more in the age of AI.

AI is already taking on the technical groundwork juniors once cut their teeth on, from research to first drafts to document review. What it can't give us is judgement, creativity and the ability to sit with a scared client and make them feel safe.

That makes human connection one of the most valuable things a firm has, and our people will increasingly look for it in their team, their firm and, above all, their leader.

With almost half of all Australian solicitors now aged between 25 and 39, our profession is younger than the leadership model it inherited, and they're already telling us what they need.

Leadership is a skill, and lawyers can learn it.

It's hard to be a beginner again when you're at the top of your game. You've spent years becoming excellent at the law, and then leadership asks you to learn something new, often in front of your peers, and for a while you're not very good at it. That's uncomfortable for anyone, but for high achievers it can be genuinely confronting.

I've had baby partners tell me they feel intimidated sitting around the leadership table, and that the other partners make it look easy. What they can't see is that those partners weren't born knowing how to lead. They learned it, often the hard way.

Leadership isn't a talent you either have or you don't. It's a skill, and you practise it, just like you learned to practise law. Nobody expected you to be a great lawyer on day one. You learned, you got things wrong, you got feedback and you kept going. Leadership works in exactly the same way.

Trust can be built, feedback is a skill and empathy is a practice. But leadership development for lawyers needs to be taught the way lawyers learn: evidence first, grounded in real legal scenarios, and with frameworks you can actually use rather than fluff.

Being a great lawyer and being a great leader are two very different things. Both matter, and both deserve our attention.

Ready to develop your firm's next leaders?

Whether you're a new partner finding your feet at the leadership table or a managing partner steering a whole firm, I work with lawyers and law firms to turn great lawyers into great leaders through coaching, workshops and leadership programs.

Let's talk about what leadership development could look like for your firm →

And if you'd like more insights like this, subscribe to Leadership in the Law, my fortnightly newsletter on the realities of leading lawyers.

Frequently asked questions

Why do lawyers leave law firms? Australian research points to workplace culture and leadership. In a 2025 ANU and University of Melbourne survey of around 1,900 lawyers, a third wanted to quit their firm, and College of Law research lists poor management and leadership among the top reasons lawyers are unhappy.

What do younger lawyers want from their leaders? Deliberate learning and coaching, specific and regular feedback, the reasoning behind decisions, and flexibility as an expectation. Underneath that sit three things: trust, sense making and believability.

Why is leadership harder for lawyers than for other professionals? Lawyers score as outliers on traits like scepticism, autonomy and urgency, and low on sociability and resilience. Those traits make lawyers excellent at legal work but make trust, delegation, listening and feedback harder as leaders.

Can leadership be learned? Yes. Leadership is a skill you practise, just like law. It's best taught the way lawyers learn: evidence first, grounded in real legal scenarios, with practical frameworks.


Sources

  • Holmes, V, Webb, J, Ainsworth, S and Foley, T, Lawyer Wellbeing, Workplace Experiences and Ethics: A Research Report, Australian National University and University of Melbourne, 2025.

  • Wellbeing in the Legal Profession: Findings from the 2025 Victorian Lawyer Census, Victorian Legal Services Board and Commissioner.

  • College of Law, Law Forward Satisfaction Survey and 2025 career research.

  • 2026 ALPMA and Elias Recruitment Australian Legal Industry HR Issues and Salary Survey.

  • Dr Larry Richard, LawyerBrain LLC, Caliper Profile research on lawyer personality, United States and Canada.

  • Urbis, National Profile of Solicitors, 2024.

About the author

Midja Fisher is The Leadership Coach for Lawyers and the founder of Midja Leadership. A former partner of a national law firm, she has more than 25 years' experience in law and leadership, has facilitated over 500 leadership workshops, and is the author of Great Lawyer to Great Leader*,* Unshakeable Confidence and Take Off the Cape*.*

Next
Next

The Leadership Squeeze: Why You’re Doing More Than Ever and Still Falling Behind